Michael Bay Vs. Hugo Weaving: A War Worth Fighting?

Posted Monday, October 22nd, 2012 01:00 pm GMT -4 by 0

Transformers

One of the most familiar sayings in Hollywood is “Be nice to the people on your way up. They may be the same people you meet on the way down.” Apparently the saying has been lost on a few people as the latest Hollywood “feud” between actor Hugo Weaving and producer/director Michael Bay has hit online amidst quite a bit of fan controversy.

Earlier last week Weaving spoke to various media outlets regarding his participation on several films. One of those comments included his reluctance (okay his extreme unwillingness) to return as Red Skull in the Marvel films. But it’s his comments about playing the voice of Megatron in the ‘Transformers’ films that seemed to hit home with Bay.

Weaving, by all means, is not the first who has come out against the director and his ‘Transformers’ franchise. Megan Fox and Shia LaBeouf both spoke out about the director/producer but it was the comments from Weaving that may have been the last straw.

In an interview with Collider, Weaving was asked if he has been asked to return for ‘Transformers 4:’

Hugo Weaving“No.  That’s a weird job for me because it honestly was a two-hour voice job, initially.  I was doing a play and I actually didn’t have time, anyway.  It was one of the only things I’ve ever done where I had no knowledge of it, I didn’t care about it, I didn’t think about it.  They wanted me to do it.  In one way, I regret that bit.  I don’t regret doing it, but I very rarely do something if it’s meaningless.  It was meaningless to me, honestly.  I don’t mean that in any nasty way.  I did it.  It was a two-hour voice job, while I was doing other things.  Of course, it’s a massive film that’s made masses of money.  I just happened to be the voice of one of the iconic villainous characters.  But, my link to that and to Michael Bay is so minimal.  I have never met him.  I was never on set.  I’ve seen his face on Skype.  I know nothing about him, really.  I just went in and did it.  I never read the script.  I just have my lines, and I don’t know what they mean.  That sounds absolutely pathetic!  I’ve never done anything like that, in my life.  It’s hard to say any more about it than that, really.”

After hearing about Weaver’s comments, Bay quickly took to his computer and blogged a rather scathing retort. Although he didn’t name names, it was quite obvious who the comment was directed at:

“Do you ever get sick of actors that make $15 million a picture, or even $200,000 for voice-over work that took a brisk one hour and 43 minutes to complete, and then complain about their jobs?

With all the problems facing our world today, do these grumbling thespians really think people reading the news actually care about trivial complaints that their job wasn’t “artistic enough” or “fulfilling enough”? [...] What happened to people who had integrity, who did a job, got paid for their hard work, and just smiled afterward? Be happy you even have a job — let alone a job that pays you more than 98% of the people in America.

I have a wonderful idea for all those whiners: They can give their “unhappy job money” to a wonderful Elephant Rescue. It’s the David Sheldrick Wildlife Trust in Africa. I will match the funds they donate.”

The post has since been taken down but not before other media outlets like THR got a hold of it. But is this a case of Bay getting his pants in a knot before really understanding what Weaving was trying to say?

Most would just take Weaving’s comments at face value. He was asked to do a voice over, he went in, read lines, met the director via Skype and got paid. He didn’t have to research the role and he didn’t have to sit in make-up or be loaded up with prosthetics to become Megatron. Compared to other roles he’s had, such as his work on ‘Cloud Atlas,’ and Elrond in the ‘Lord of the Rings’ and ‘The Hobbit’ trilogies, reading lines in a recording studio can be considered “meaningless” although a better word to have described the experience would have been better utilized.

Bay on the other hand, may have jumped the gun with his response but this is not anything new. His responses to his latest changes for the reboot of ‘Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles’ sparked a firestorm of derision among Turtle fans. And when Megan Fox decided to compare Bay to Hitler, he also sharply responded by saying:

“Well, that’s Megan Fox for you. She says some very ridiculous things because she’s 23 years old and she still has a lot of growing to do. You roll your eyes when you see statements like that and think, ‘OK Megan, you can do whatever you want. I got it. Nick Cage wasn’t a big actor when I cast him, nor was Ben Affleck before I put him in Armageddon. Shia LaBeouf wasn’t a big movie star before he did Transformers – and then he exploded. Nobody in the world knew about Megan Fox until I found her and put her in Transformers.”

Whether it was common sense or Hasbro calling Bay up and telling him to play nice, his post to Weaving’s comments can no longer be found but has the damage already been done? What is known is that the ‘Transformers’ franchise is Bay’s baby, and like a mother tiger protecting its cub, Bay will not allow anyone to belittle his work.

Will this be the end of Megatron? After all, he was killed in the last film. Or do you think Weaving has a point? Whether you are on Team Bay or Team Weaving, it looks like this battle of who is more important in the business may continue to be fought behind the scenes.

  • brendanbiryla

    “But is this a case of Bay getting his pants in a knot before really understanding what Weaving was trying to say?”

    It seems pretty clear what Weaving said, no?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Else-Harbeau/1232374532 Else Harbeau

    Bay and some fanboys (and misguided “journalists” like those at THR, who ensured the incident would blow up by quoting Weaving out of context and surrounding his remarks with bad insult comedy) might want to frame this as a “war”, but I am certain Weaving never meant his remarks to be taken that way. He was simply answering an off-topic question about a franchise he no longer has an association with when trying to promote a much more important film. Bay was clearly targeting more than one person, because Weaving has never earned anything close to 15 million for a role. (Bay has alienated so many actors in recent years that it’s hard to keep track.) Weaving owes Bay exactly NOTHING. Weaving was getting offers to play one-note villains in action films the moment The Matrix came out, and Bay was just another Hollywood hack wanting a variation on Agent Smith.

    Weaving’s mistake in this sorry episode was thinking the franchise’s fans (and director) are mature enough to understand that this is, in fact, a minor voice role and that most such roles aren’t a dominating force in actors’ lives. But Transformers fans seem to think that being paid for even the most negligible role in these films requires a lifetime of exhaustive intel about the minutiae of the characters and an eagerness to be asked repeatedly about these films no matter what else you want to do. Oh, and wanting to do more substantive work will be called “pretentious” and “whiny” by people who never see films outside the fantasy genre and think whatever films earn the most should be those that an actor loves the most, even if those offer him nothing of substance.

    Bay might have given Meagan Fox a career boost (for whatever that’s worth…) but the rest of his rambling ego broadside only makes him look like the juvenile tyrant he is. He makes more money than the people he’s attacking, many times over. Weaving wasn’t complaining and never attacked Bay personally. He merely said he’d never met him or been given a complete script. Actors are allowed to find some jobs more meaningful than others, and to choose the roles they find most rewarding, even if that means making less money for doing something “artistic”. Some of us actually prefer art to bombastic drivel designed primarily to sell toys. Weaving is showing integrity and honesty while Bay has an overinflated notion of his own importance. I’m certain Weaving, who doesn’t go online or pay attention to pop cultural gossip, has no idea a few minor comments he made have been so blown out of proportion. But he had a thriving, diverse career before Bay offered the talking robot gig, and will continue to have one.

    • brendanbiryla

      You sound like you’re on weavings PR team…. Regardless, Weaving was overly dismissive of a relatively tame question and it’s probably true that the check for the gig was bigger than most american’s make in a year. He could have made a more graceful statement saying he’s glad to have lended is voice to an iconic villian but is looking forward to moving onto other things… next question….

  • dusk

    Should have just got the original Megatron’s voice actor to do the movie’s version. Last I checked, he still functions, portraying a terrific Megatron in Transformers Prime. Hollywood, sigh…